The small city of Frisco, Texas, is dealing with a tragic event that has gained attention across the country. In April 2025, 17-year-old Austin Metcalf was killed in a stabbing during a high school track meet at Memorial High School. Another teenager, Karmelo Anthony, is now facing legal charges in this case. As the case moves through the court system, people are asking important questions about justice, race, and how young people are treated in the legal system.
The Incident and Its Immediate Aftermath
On April 2, 2025, during a track and field championship at Kuykendall Stadium in Frisco, an altercation broke out between two students: Austin Metcalf, a junior at Frisco Memorial High School, and Karmelo Anthony, a student at Frisco Centennial High School. According to police affidavits and eyewitness accounts, Metcalf had asked Anthony to leave the event because he did not attend Memorial High School. The situation escalated quickly.
Surveillance footage released by Frisco ISD shows a sudden movement under a tent near the 50-yard line of the field at about 9:55 a.m., followed by interaction between two individuals—later identified as Metcalf and Anthony. This is believed to be the moment the stabbing occurred. Witnesses reported seeing Anthony grab his bag, reach inside, and warn Metcalf, “Touch me and see what happens.” When Metcalf did touch him, Anthony allegedly pulled out a knife and stabbed Metcalf in the chest.
Metcalf was found suffering from a stab wound when police arrived. He was rushed to a local hospital but was pronounced dead soon after. His twin brother, Hunter Metcalf, was with him at the time and held him as he died, later recounting the harrowing experience to local media.
Karmelo Anthony was taken into custody at the scene. He reportedly asked police if Metcalf would be alright and inquired whether his actions could be considered self-defense.
Arrest, Charges, and Legal Proceedings
Anthony was initially arrested and charged with first-degree murder. His bail was set at $1 million, but following a bond hearing, it was reduced to $250,000, a decision that sparked significant backlash from the community and threats against the presiding judge, Collin County Judge Angela Tucker. Anthony was released on bond on April 14, 2025, and placed under strict house arrest conditions, including wearing an ankle monitor, avoiding social media and school contact, and needing court approval to leave home.
The case has been notable for its prosecution under Texas’ “concurrent jurisdiction” or “direct file” laws, which allow prosecutors to charge minors as adults for serious crimes without judicial oversight. This policy has been criticized for disproportionately affecting Black and brown youth, and has been the subject of reform efforts across the country. Karmelo Anthony, who is Black, is being tried as an adult for the death of Austin Metcalf, who was white.
On June 24, 2025, a Collin County grand jury formally indicted Anthony on a first-degree murder charge. The indictment means the case will proceed to trial unless a plea agreement is reached. If convicted, Anthony could face a mandatory life sentence, though as a 17-year-old at the time of the offense, he would be eligible for parole after 40 years under Texas law.
Community Reaction and Public Debate
The incident has deeply affected the Frisco community and beyond. Collin County District Attorney Greg Willis acknowledged that Metcalf’s death “struck a deep nerve” in the community, emphasizing that the justice system must move “with steadiness and with principle”. The tragedy has also highlighted the emotional toll on both families, with Austin Metcalf’s father speaking publicly about the loss of his son and the presence of his twin brother at the scene.
On the other side, Karmelo Anthony’s family has faced intense scrutiny, threats, and harassment. His mother, Kala Hayes, spoke out for the first time in mid-April, describing the toll the case has taken on her family. “In the wake of this tragic incident, our family has been under attack,” she said. “Whatever you think happened… my three younger children, my husband and I didn’t do anything to deserve to be threatened, harassed, and lied about.” Hayes added that her husband had to take a leave of absence from his job due to fear for their safety, and that their mental health has deteriorated as a result of the ongoing threats.
Both families have called for an end to the threats and online harassment, with Anthony’s defense attorney, Mike Howard, emphasizing that “the vitriol, threats, and talk of race and war are not helping anyone. This is a tragedy for both families and the community”.
Legal Defense and Advocacy
Anthony’s lawyer, Mike Howard, and a group that supports social justice, the Next Generation Action Network, say that Anthony was protecting himself. Howard said, “We believe that once the jury hears all the facts and the full story, they will make the right decision and justice will be served.”
The case has become more difficult because many people are talking about it online, and some of the information being shared is not true. Police have warned that false stories are spreading on social media. Both Anthony’s family and the other family involved have been hurt by the negative reactions. Anthony’s family also had to deal with fake fundraising websites claiming to collect money for them, but they have said those pages are not real.
As of June 2025, a real fundraiser on GiveSendGo.com has raised over $530,000 to help pay for the family’s legal costs and other needs. The family said they did not get the money right away, but it will be used for legal and related costs as the case continues.
The Broader Context: Juvenile Justice and Race
The Karmelo Anthony case has brought renewed attention to the issue of how minors are treated in the criminal justice system, particularly in Texas. The state’s direct file laws allow prosecutors to charge juveniles as adults for serious offenses, a practice that has been criticized for its disproportionate impact on Black and brown youth. According to a report from The Sentencing Project, Texas ranks among the states with the highest number of individuals under 25 serving life sentences, and more than half of those sentenced to life without parole from 1995 to 2017 were Black.
Advocates for juvenile justice reform have pointed to the Anthony case as an example of why these laws need to be revisited. Since 2008, there have been hundreds of efforts to reform direct file laws or introduce second-chance legislation across the country, with limited success in Texas. The case has also sparked debate about the role of race in both the legal system and public perception of crime.
The Path Forward
With the grand jury’s indictment, the case against Karmelo Anthony is set to move forward in the courts. The prosecution will present evidence to support the first-degree murder charge, while the defense will argue that Anthony acted in self-defense. The trial is expected to be closely watched, not only for its legal implications but also for its broader social significance.
Community leaders, legal experts, and advocates continue to call for calm and for the public to allow the justice system to work. The tragedy has already left an indelible mark on the Frisco community, and the outcome of the case will likely have lasting implications for both families and for the ongoing debate over juvenile justice in Texas and beyond.
Conclusion
The Karmelo Anthony case is a complex and heart-wrenching story of loss, legal controversy, and community division. As the legal process unfolds, it serves as a stark reminder of the impact of violence on young lives and the challenges of achieving justice in an era of heightened public scrutiny and social media misinformation. The case also highlights the urgent need for thoughtful discussion and reform regarding how the justice system treats minors, especially those from marginalized communities.
Both families—grieving and under pressure—have asked for privacy and an end to the threats and harassment. As the community mourns Austin Metcalf and grapples with the legal fate of Karmelo Anthony, the hope is that justice will be served with fairness and compassion for all involved.
Also read:
